PMO story
The project that stayed green for nine months
Short answer
Self-reported RAG hides slips because the person reporting is also the person being judged. Calculate health from dates, progress and overdue work, and ask three questions every month: what moved, what is overdue, and what decision is needed.
Month one: everything is green
The programme had four workstreams, a confident programme manager and a sponsor who trusted the weekly slide. Every workstream reported green, and that was true: the plan was new and nothing had had time to slip.
Month two: the first quiet slip
The data-migration workstream missed its first internal milestone by a week. The lead moved the date in the plan “to reflect reality” and kept the status green, because the go-live date hadn’t changed.
Question that would have caught it: What moved since last month? A baseline comparison shows the slip on the day it happens.
Months three to eight: the watermelon
Green outside, red inside. Each workstream absorbed small slips into contingency. Overdue tasks piled up in the tracker, but the status slide came from a separate spreadsheet that people filled in by hand.
Question that would have caught it: What is overdue right now? If overdue work counts towards health automatically, a project can’t stay green with 40 overdue tasks.
Month nine: red, all at once
Two months before go-live, testing found that the migrated data could not be reconciled. The programme turned red in a single steering committee, and the sponsor asked the question nobody wanted: “Why am I hearing this now?”
Question that would have caught it: What decision do you need from me? Asked every month, it gives people a safe way to raise problems early.
What the PMO changed
- Health is calculated, not declared. One rule for every project: overdue milestones make it red; otherwise the progress score sets green, amber or red.
- Baselines are frozen at gate 3. Moving a date creates a visible variance instead of overwriting the plan.
- Every report ends with “decisions needed”. If there are none, the report says so.